Lawyers who don't want to produce information or documents that the other side has requested often accuse them of engaging in a "fishing expedition."
Indeed, "fishing expedition" is the cliche of choice under these circumstances. Over the years, countless litigants have invoked the phrase and countless judges have adopted it as a metaphor to describe the problem of discovery run amok.
The phrase should be sent off to enjoy its long overdue retirement .... and perhaps enjoy a little angling.
This is so for at least two reasons.
First, the metaphor is inapt. Fishing does not involve an indiscriminate effort to see if there is anything anywhere in the lake. To the contrary, it requires a studied understanding of what one wants to catch, where one might find it, and how one might get it on the line.
Second, the metaphor reflects a misunderstaning of the law. In fact, the modern discovery rules give litigants substantial latitude to test the waters with less than perfect precision.
But don't take my word for it. The United States Supreme Court said as much in Hickman v. Taylor (1947), where it observed this about discovery under the federal rules of civil procedure: "No longer can the time-honored cry of 'fishing expedition' serve to preclude a party from inquiring into the facts underlying his opponent's case."
That was more than sixty years ago. The news does not appear to have reached many lawyers and judges.
Perhaps they were off fishing when the word came down.
Len Niehoff is Professor from Practice at the University of Michigan Law School, where he teaches courses in civil procedure, ethics, evidence, First Amendment, law & theology, and media law. He writes regularly in all of these fields. He is also Of Counsel to the Honigman law firm. The opinions expressed here are his own.
Tuesday, February 8, 2011
Monday, February 7, 2011
Roger That
Last Sunday, the Los Angeles Times published an intriguing op-ed by Akhil Reed Amar critiquing federal District Judge Roger Vinson's decision holding "Obamacare" unconstitutional. You can find the article here.
Professor Amar concludes by comparing Judge Vinson's misunderstanding of constitutional first principles with that of "another judge named Roger"--Supreme Court Justice Roger Taney, the author of the infamous Dred Scott decision.
I am not persuaded that the curiously undisciplined and bewilderingly confused opinion of an isolated federal district court judge ranks with Dred Scott in whatever scale we use to measure magnitudes of evil. But the article has considerable rhetorical force and is a fun read.
Professor Amar concludes by comparing Judge Vinson's misunderstanding of constitutional first principles with that of "another judge named Roger"--Supreme Court Justice Roger Taney, the author of the infamous Dred Scott decision.
I am not persuaded that the curiously undisciplined and bewilderingly confused opinion of an isolated federal district court judge ranks with Dred Scott in whatever scale we use to measure magnitudes of evil. But the article has considerable rhetorical force and is a fun read.
Thursday, February 3, 2011
The Persistence of Ideas
Kevin Kelly of Wired Magazine believes that no human invention ever goes extinct. National Public Radio has recently had some fun with this, challenging its listeners to identify an invention that the world has stopped producing. It turns out that Kelly may well be right; finding something that absolutely no one makes any more is a daunting task. You can learn more about the debate here.
I suspect that Kelly's point is just part of a broader one: no idea ever goes extinct. Justice Holmes's familiar metaphor maintains that ideas compete for allegiance in the marketplace of free expression. Yes, but it is important to remember that this process does not cast the losers into exile. It just relegates them to the darker corners, where they can continue to serve the customers who still patronize them.
So do not feign astonishment when obnoxious doctrines, long thought extinct, reappear. No idea ever goes out of production. No idea, no matter how pernicious, ever falls entirely from use.
I suspect that Kelly's point is just part of a broader one: no idea ever goes extinct. Justice Holmes's familiar metaphor maintains that ideas compete for allegiance in the marketplace of free expression. Yes, but it is important to remember that this process does not cast the losers into exile. It just relegates them to the darker corners, where they can continue to serve the customers who still patronize them.
So do not feign astonishment when obnoxious doctrines, long thought extinct, reappear. No idea ever goes out of production. No idea, no matter how pernicious, ever falls entirely from use.
Monday, January 31, 2011
Unringing the Bell
Taco Bell has responded to a lawsuit alleging that its beef mixture contains more filler than meat by taking out full page ads declaring "thank you for suing us." A CNNMoney.com report on the campaign can be found here.
A number of commentators have wondered about the wisdom of the strategy. After all, whatever its other virtues, the civil justice system has a poor record as a "name clearing" mechanism.
Just ask the Texas cattlemen who sued Oprah Winfrey over her statements about beef (that unquestionably was beef) and lost. Of course, they didn't just lose; they lost to one of the most popular personalities in America .... who had her own television talk show. It is hard to believe that, in retrospect, they still think this was a good idea.
But matters are even more complicated for Taco Bell. Its problem is being driven by social media, which moves at the speed of light. Litigation, which moves at the pace of your average glacier, will never catch up.
Over many years in practice I encountered numerous businesses and individuals who were excited about being sued because of the opportunity for "vindication" it afforded. It rarely played out that way. In general, they would have done better to take a deep breath and recall the words of the distinguished jurist Learned Hand: "As a litigant, I should dread a lawsuit beyond almost anything short of sickness and death."
A number of commentators have wondered about the wisdom of the strategy. After all, whatever its other virtues, the civil justice system has a poor record as a "name clearing" mechanism.
Just ask the Texas cattlemen who sued Oprah Winfrey over her statements about beef (that unquestionably was beef) and lost. Of course, they didn't just lose; they lost to one of the most popular personalities in America .... who had her own television talk show. It is hard to believe that, in retrospect, they still think this was a good idea.
But matters are even more complicated for Taco Bell. Its problem is being driven by social media, which moves at the speed of light. Litigation, which moves at the pace of your average glacier, will never catch up.
Over many years in practice I encountered numerous businesses and individuals who were excited about being sued because of the opportunity for "vindication" it afforded. It rarely played out that way. In general, they would have done better to take a deep breath and recall the words of the distinguished jurist Learned Hand: "As a litigant, I should dread a lawsuit beyond almost anything short of sickness and death."
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
The Free Market of Ideas
The most recent issue of The Nation published a debate between Floyd Abrams and Burt Neuborne over the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United. The online version of the article can be found here. The exchange is intelligent, lively, and engaging.
Still, I think that the authors miss one of the most interesting aspects of the case: that it serves as a jurisprudential Rorschach test for one's view of political liberty.
Some people believe that the preservation of liberty requires at least some regulation. Advocates for this position believe that the marketplace of ideas cannot survive, let alone flourish, unless it operates within constraints that help foster openness and fair play. This is the view reflected in the campaign restrictions that the Supreme Court held invalid.
Another view holds that regulation is inherently antithetical to the preservation of liberty. Advocates for this position believe that censorship in the cause of freedom is intellectually incoherent. This is the view embraced by those who see Citizens United as a triumph of First Amendment values.
I believe that either position is defensible. But I also believe that consistency matters here. Vacillation between these views suggests a jurisprudence of convenience, where the operative paradigm changes from case to case in order to achieve the outcome desired.
It will be interesting to see whether the Court's future First Amendment decisions are consistent with the expansive free market sensibility reflected in Citizens United. As to that, there can be no debate.
Still, I think that the authors miss one of the most interesting aspects of the case: that it serves as a jurisprudential Rorschach test for one's view of political liberty.
Some people believe that the preservation of liberty requires at least some regulation. Advocates for this position believe that the marketplace of ideas cannot survive, let alone flourish, unless it operates within constraints that help foster openness and fair play. This is the view reflected in the campaign restrictions that the Supreme Court held invalid.
Another view holds that regulation is inherently antithetical to the preservation of liberty. Advocates for this position believe that censorship in the cause of freedom is intellectually incoherent. This is the view embraced by those who see Citizens United as a triumph of First Amendment values.
I believe that either position is defensible. But I also believe that consistency matters here. Vacillation between these views suggests a jurisprudence of convenience, where the operative paradigm changes from case to case in order to achieve the outcome desired.
It will be interesting to see whether the Court's future First Amendment decisions are consistent with the expansive free market sensibility reflected in Citizens United. As to that, there can be no debate.
Thursday, December 16, 2010
Judges All A-Twitter
Earlier this year, the Communications Lawyer published an article ("Of Tweets and Trials," 27 Communications Lawyer 3, September 2010) where I pointed out that the phenomenon of social media is forcing judges to rethink the measures they take to ensure that the trials over which they preside are conducted in a fair and orderly manner.
In that article, I focused on the impact of social media on the "gag orders" that judges enter against parties, witnesses, and attorneys and on the instructions that judges give to jurors.
My friend Dave Farrell brought to my attention an interesting piece from yesterday's online edition of the Guardian that can be found here. The article praises a British judge's decision to allow tweeting from the courtroom during the Julian Assange extradition hearing. It argues that there is no principled basis on which to distinguish real-time tweeting in the courtroom from the journalist's long-recognized right to take notes on what happens in open court, walk into the hallway, and phone the story in.
The argument has a lot of appeal, although questions obviously remain. Does the character limitation of tweets work against their accuracy? Is the real-time nature of the medium inconsitent with the kind of reflection that provides depth and context to a report? Should judges allow journalists to tweet in their courtrooms, but not members of the general public? If so, then which category do bloggers fall into?
Judges throughout the United States who find themselves presiding over high-profile trials are looking for answers. Are they finding any?
Stay tuned.
In that article, I focused on the impact of social media on the "gag orders" that judges enter against parties, witnesses, and attorneys and on the instructions that judges give to jurors.
My friend Dave Farrell brought to my attention an interesting piece from yesterday's online edition of the Guardian that can be found here. The article praises a British judge's decision to allow tweeting from the courtroom during the Julian Assange extradition hearing. It argues that there is no principled basis on which to distinguish real-time tweeting in the courtroom from the journalist's long-recognized right to take notes on what happens in open court, walk into the hallway, and phone the story in.
The argument has a lot of appeal, although questions obviously remain. Does the character limitation of tweets work against their accuracy? Is the real-time nature of the medium inconsitent with the kind of reflection that provides depth and context to a report? Should judges allow journalists to tweet in their courtrooms, but not members of the general public? If so, then which category do bloggers fall into?
Judges throughout the United States who find themselves presiding over high-profile trials are looking for answers. Are they finding any?
Stay tuned.
Friday, December 10, 2010
What the Bird Heard
Here's an intriguing puzzle for students of evidence.
A 60-year-old South Carolina woman has been charged with abusing and neglecting her 98-year-old mother. The evidence against her includes, of all things, statements made by a parrot. Police report that the parrot was mimicking the phrase "Help me! Help me!" and then laughing. They believe the parrot is repeating the cries for help from the mother and the mocking laughter of the daughter. The ABA Journal report on the story can be found here.
There are several obvious obstacles to admitting the bird's statements into evidence. Surely one of the most significant is authentication. How do we know whose statements they really are? How do we know when they were made? How do we know that the parrot is accurately repeating what it heard?
Life, we learn once again, is strange. Even stranger than the imaginations of law professors who have to write Evidence exams.
A 60-year-old South Carolina woman has been charged with abusing and neglecting her 98-year-old mother. The evidence against her includes, of all things, statements made by a parrot. Police report that the parrot was mimicking the phrase "Help me! Help me!" and then laughing. They believe the parrot is repeating the cries for help from the mother and the mocking laughter of the daughter. The ABA Journal report on the story can be found here.
There are several obvious obstacles to admitting the bird's statements into evidence. Surely one of the most significant is authentication. How do we know whose statements they really are? How do we know when they were made? How do we know that the parrot is accurately repeating what it heard?
Life, we learn once again, is strange. Even stranger than the imaginations of law professors who have to write Evidence exams.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)